Well my procrastination and focus on other things paid off as not getting around to the player review allows me to include
the new salary information that dropped today.
We're going to go by position (roughly) and include their current contract status. Numbers are the base salary, there's also numbers for the 2026 guaranteed salary out there but that's some weird math that the union does that includes counting option years and such. Contract years are weird because contracts signed in the last year all end at the end of seasons on the new schedule while older contracts all end at the end of seasons on the old schedule.
* - International
DP - Designated Player
U-22 - U-22 Player
Goalkeepers:
Zack Steffen - $1.1M - Option for 2027
Nico Hansen - $116K - Guaranteed through 27-28, options through 29-30
Adam Beaudry - $113K - Guaranteed for 2027, options through 2029
Zack, thank you for your service, good luck wherever you end up. There's just no good reason to spend that much on a keeper when Nico can do good enough and we can use that cap room elsewhere. Steffen was streaky before he got injured and I'd rather take my chances with a couple of guys who make less than $250K combined. We should look at bringing an experienced backup in to help but not spending big money there. Also if Nico has a good sprint season we should probably give him some more money.
Outside Backs:
Reggie Cannon - $750K - Guaranteed through 2027, option for 2028
Miguel Navarro - $500K - Loan ending, rumored $1M purchase clause
Keegan Rosenberry - $300K - Guaranteed through 2027
Kosi Thompson - $140K - Out of contract
Jackson Travis - $125K - Option for 2027
The bad news is that outside of Navarro none of these guys had a good season. The good news is that outside of Cannon they were all fairly cheap. I would exercise the buy option on Navarro if it really is at $1M (or in that area). Otherwise none of this group is our future. Cannon should be released as soon as the offset contract allows it. He does a lot of things, but none of them better than average. Keegan is fine as the veteran presence in the locker room for as long as he wants that role at that type of number but he's not a starter. Thompson is a card magnet and Travis isn't ready. Both of them are on homegrown deals which means re-signing them doesn't hurt us bit they're depth options, no more. We need to go find a right back this offseason that can take minutes from Cannon.
Center Backs:
Rob Holding - $1.2M - Out of contract
Loic Williams - $853K - Guaranteed through 29-30, option for 30-31*
Noah Cobb - $125K - Option for 2027
That's...light. Only one true central defender with any experience under contract for next season. I think you have to pick up Cobb's option just for depth but he's not ready to be a starter. Because of that its worth bringing Holding back, at the right number. I'd prefer to see him in the $850K region where he would be a max salary player but maybe a small amount of TAM is worth it. He should not get a raise though. We need to sign a player that can compete for MLS minutes if we re-sign Holding and we need to sign a lock-down starter and one who can compete for minutes if we don't.
Central Midfielders:
Paxten Aaronson - $2M - Guaranteed through 2030 - DP
Youssef Maziz - $950K Guaranteed through 27-28, option for 28-29*
Hamzat Ojediran - $800K - Guaranteed through 28-29, options through 30-31*
Josh Atencio - $462K - Guaranteed through 2027, option for 2028
Wayne Frederick - $300K - Guaranteed through 29-30, option for 30-31
This is where the rubber starts meeting the road. High priced players but for the most part earning their keep. Aaronson was the best player for the Rapids that was here all season. You'd like a bit more but with the roster changes around him its hard to put that all on him. Maziz looked good until his injury, hopefully he bounces back with good seasons in 2027. Wayne Fredrick stepped up, took almost all the minutes that Bassett would have played, and finished only a goal and an assist behind what Cole did in Portland (and 3 assists ahead of what Cole did here last year). For less than half the price as a younger player with longer left on his contract.
The big challenge here is the Ojediran/Atencio battle. You really don't need them on the field at the same time unless you're defending a lead late. I favored Ojediran this season but the advanced numbers show Atencio was the more valuable player. Of course that only matters if he's not suspended. Atencio tied for second in total cards this year with 11 yellows, one off the lead. Everyone else above 10 played 300-800 minutes more than him though, which means on a cards vs. time basis Atencio was the clear league leader. That's a real problem. I want to see Wells figure out how to use Ojediran's strengths more next season and rely less on Atencio. Overall this is a solid group to build around though.
Wingers:
Morgan Whittaker - $1.8M - Guaranteed through 29-30, option for 30-31 - DP*
Ted Ku-Dipietro - $500K - Guaranteed through 2027, option for 2028 - U-22
Ibrahim Sadiq - $650K - Guaranateed through 27-28, option for 28-29
Georgi Minoungou - $113K - Guaranteed through 2028, option for 2029*
Alex Harris - $88K - Guaranteed for 2027, options through 2029
Kimani Stewart-Baynes - $115K - Options through 2028
This group, on the other hand, isn't great. Whittaker looks like a really good signing, the only concern is we signed him as a winger but used him as a forward because of issues there. I don't love playing the biggest signing in club history out of position almost immediately, but if it works it works. I hammered on Minoungou a lot of this season because of what we paid for him, but from a salary basis he's great value. He hasn't earned a new contract yet but he's earned a chance to claim a starting spot in camp.
Ted KDP is made of glass and is playing for his contract next year, if he can't stay on the field there's no reason to extend him. We didn't see much of Sadiq but that would be KDP's biggest competition. Harris is on a GA contract and is fine as depth but no more. KSB should be allowed to walk away.
We need to sign at least one reliable backup here and hope Minoungou or Sadiq can lock down a spot across from Whittaker. If not we'll be in the market for a starting winger, again.
Forwards:
Sayed Abu Farchi - $800K - Guaranteed through 29-30, option for 30-31, U-22*
Darren Yapi - $795K - Guaranteed through 28-29, option for 29-30, U-22
Donovan Phillip $88K - Guaranteed through sprint, options through 29-30*
*sigh* These guys combined for 8 goals, and 37% of then cane from the guy making less than $100K. This group is awful. Yeah, yeah, small sample size for Farchi but when your big forward signing finishes with more cards than shots on target that's a bad thing. And Yapi always seems to be one season away from breaking out, but never breaks out. Phillip is a real find it seems but we have to do better here. If we're stuck with Farchi then he's got to get better quickly or we'll need to sign somebody over the top of him.
Everyone Else:
Bryan Dowd - Options through 27-28
Bryce Jamison - $113K - Guaranteed through 2027, options through 2029
Mamadou Billo Diop - $88K, Guaranteed through 27-28, options through 29-30*
Ali Fadal - $113K, Options through 2028,*
Sydney Wathuta - $88K, Guaranteed through sprint, options through 28-29
Grant Gilmore - $88K - Guaranteed through 2029, options through 2031
Most of these guys got 0 minutes with the first team or maybe some Open Cup minutes. I couldn't tell you anything about them. Dowd was signed as an emergency when we needed a backup keeper and were out of short-term callups from Rapids 2. I doubt he returns. Hard to justify keeping Fadal on an international slot given his lack of contributions. The other four will be back but I don't expect anything out of them next year.
One final note. Rafa Navarro's new contract in St. Louis has him guaranteed through 2029-30 at $3.7M, with an option year in 30-31. That's a significant increase on his $1.4M here in Colorado. Its also just above the combined salary of Whiattaker, Farchi, and Maziz. So we've got a good comparison point. Do those three signings, made in the window where we sold Navarro, generate a similar amount of offense that Rafa does?